On the surface, Bruce Springsteen is the workingman’s troubadour—the bard of highways and mill towns. But for a Black listener, his voice carries another weight: it echoes the sorrow songs, borrows from Black survival, & exposes the fracture at America’s core.
1/15
#history #photography #music #blackandwhite #blackmastodon #histodons #newjersey
Image: Bruce Springsteen Up The River with Clarence Clemons, Dec 31, 1980, Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, Uniondale, NY, Photographer: Brooks Kraft.

In 1985, Springsteen was in a Guthrie documentary. He rasped through Ain’t Got No Home. My reaction was instant: that guy can’t sing. I was raised on gospel and soul, where truth meant clarity. Sam Cooke, Aretha, voices polished by fire.
https://vimeo.com/15502521.
2/15
Video: Folkways: A Vision Shared – A Tribute to Woody Guthrie and Leadbelly. Directed by Jim Brown. 1988.

But, Springsteen's roughness was its own refusal. His voice did not beautify; it refused to sand down America’s broken promises. Guthrie appealed to him because the older man's ragged tone carried protest, not polish—an inheritance of lament closer to the wail than to the hymn.
3/15
Image: Black and white poster announcing Woody Guthrie performance at Towne Forum, Los Angeles, 1941. Photo by Seema Weatherwax.

To understand this inheritance you must go back: to ring shouts, hush arbors, the “sorrow songs” Du Bois called the nation’s greatest gift. Spirituals that bore weight and coded escape—"Wade in the Water," "Swing Low," "Steal Away." They carried endurance in bent notes.
4/15
Image: Postcard of Black American prisoners leased to build the railroad in Asheville, North Carolina, January 2, 1892, Photographer T.H. Lindsey.

This music—the “changing same” Amiri Baraka named—flowed into blues hollers, gospel moans, Delta cries. Guthrie absorbed it in migrant camps: "Take This Hammer," "John Henry," cotton-field chants. Black cadence became the grammar of American protest.
5/15
https://youtu.be/0SMfDbOJlqE?si=Za5tnKZm05lIai9DVideo:
Video: Blind Lemon Jefferson, "See That My Grave Is Kept Clean," Recorded in Chicago, IL, circa February, 1928.

The folk revival claimed this current but canonized it white. Seeger, Dylan, the Weavers—borrowing Black idioms while naming Guthrie saint. When Springsteen appeared rasping Guthrie, he sealed the line: white troubadour as vessel of grievance built on Black song.
6/15
https://youtu.be/TxMORIhbFl4?si=9i-mZYGgAfUFSjl2Video:
Video: Sharon Jones and the Dap Kings perform "This Land is Your Land," Jimmy Kimmel, October 30, 2012.

For a Black listener, the paradox is sharp. One hears the idioms of survival—gospel cadences, blues refrains—but carried by a white bard. The authenticity others celebrate is borrowed from black inheritance, black sorrow turned anthem for another crowd.
7/15
https://youtu.be/yC3_ONtSEiU?si=0IQV6wwDazONAHdLVideo
Video: "Hoe, Emma, Hoe," Slave songs performed by Larry Earl Jr., Christina Lane and Willie Wright, Part of the The Music of Washington's World series, Mt. Vernon, 2015.

And yet, the music itself complicates. "Tunnel of Love" revealed a Springsteen stripped bare, confessional, fragile. Not mythic America, but human longing. He leaned closer to gospel wail than bar-band chant. It was sincerity, not invention, that carried him.
8/15
Video: Bruce Springsteen, Tunnel of Love (Columbia Records, 1987).

https://youtu.be/T8xq0j57VPc?si=FLvd1qoDt3LCoFZmAlt t

Clarence Clemons made this plain. On the cover of "Born to Run," Springsteen leaned on him—literally. Clemons’s horn was no ornament; it was the sound of transcendence. Without Clemons, there was no Springsteen. And without the blues, there is no folk, no rock and roll.
9/15
Image: The original cover of Springsteen's “Born to Run” from 1975. Photographer, Eric Meola.