Salta al contenuto
0
  • Categorie
  • Recenti
  • Tag
  • Popolare
  • Mondo
  • Utenti
  • Gruppi
  • Categorie
  • Recenti
  • Tag
  • Popolare
  • Mondo
  • Utenti
  • Gruppi
Collassa

Forum Federato

Di Piero Bosio
  1. Home
  2. Categorie
  3. Senza categoria
  4. reading over @Edent's recent post¹ about the conflict between giving users control over their own devices vs locking down phones to a blessed app-store, a piece of me wants to make app-permission-granting exceptionally onerous.

reading over @Edent's recent post¹ about the conflict between giving users control over their own devices vs locking down phones to a blessed app-store, a piece of me wants to make app-permission-granting exceptionally onerous.

Pianificato Fissato Bloccato Spostato Senza categoria
1 Post 1 Autori 0 Visualizzazioni
  • Da Vecchi a Nuovi
  • Da Nuovi a Vecchi
  • Più Voti
Rispondi
  • Topic risposta
Effettua l'accesso per rispondere
Questa discussione è stata eliminata. Solo gli utenti con diritti di gestione possono vederla.
  • Tim Chaseundefined Questo utente è esterno a questo forum
    Tim Chaseundefined Questo utente è esterno a questo forum
    Tim Chase
    scritto su ultima modifica di
    #1

    reading over @Edent's recent post¹ about the conflict between giving users control over their own devices vs locking down phones to a blessed app-store, a piece of me wants to make app-permission-granting exceptionally onerous.
    ▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁
    Allow this application:
    🔘⎺̲) to edit SMS or MMS messages
    🔘⎺̲) to read SMS or MMS messages
    🔘⎺̲) to receive SMS messages
    (⎺̲🔘 to know your coarse (network-based) location
    🔘⎺̲) to know your fine (GPS-based) location
    to create Bluetooth connections
    🔘⎺̲) full internet access
    🔘⎺̲) to modify/delete SD card contents
    🔘⎺̲) to make phone calls
    🔘⎺̲) to answer phone calls
    [Okay] [Cancel]
    ▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔
    Would it suck to install an application that requires permission overreach because you'd have to manually grant every requested permission? You betcha. Would it make devs have to think about how much pain they want to inflict on possible users? One would hope.

    But frankly, I'd love to have this level of permission-granularity at install time. You're a freakin' barcode management application for my library cards. You don't need to access my files or to make internet connections or overlay on other running applications. You just need to show the barcode on the screen, adjust screen-brightness, and possibly use the camera to scan existing barcodes. (not that I have particularly bitter experiences with barcode apps in particular)

    ⸻
    ¹ https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2025/08/is-it-possible-to-allow-sideloading-and-keep-users-safe/

    1 Risposta Ultima Risposta
    1
    • Stefano Marinelliundefined Stefano Marinelli ha condiviso questa discussione
    Rispondi
    • Topic risposta
    Effettua l'accesso per rispondere
    • Da Vecchi a Nuovi
    • Da Nuovi a Vecchi
    • Più Voti


    • Accedi

    • Accedi o registrati per effettuare la ricerca.
    • Primo post
      Ultimo post